55th Meeting of the Expert Panel on Social, Environmental and Economic Performance of Cotton Production – SEEP
Tuesday, 21 November 2023 7:00 am ET
Virtual – Teams
Members:
Ms. Elke Hortmeyer, EU
Mr. Leon Picon, Turkey
Mr. Jens Soth, EU
Mr. Ali Farman, Pakistan
Dr. Ryan Kurtz, USA
Mr. Fábio Carneiro, Brazil
Dr. Marcelo Paytas, Argentina
ICAC Secretariat:
Ms. Lorena Ruiz, Economist
Observer:
Dr. Kater Hake, USA
Introduction and Adoption of the Agenda
ICAC economist Lorena Ruiz initiated the meeting by welcoming delegates and thanking Dr. Kater Hake for presenting key points from the regenerative agriculture draft report. Ms. Ruiz stated the report, funded by the ICAC, was a response to SEEP members’ recommendation to create a framework that illustrates how collective efforts can contribute to a more regenerative agricultural system. The agenda was then formally adopted by the members present.
- Regenerative Agriculture Draft Report
Ms. Ruiz gave the floor to Dr. Kater Hake and asked him to provide a brief summary of the main findings of the draft report. Dr Hake shared his process of compiling a list of regenerative practices and differentiating between intended outcomes and actual grower practices. He emphasized the importance of considering what growers could feasibly implement. Dr. Kater highlighted that his analysis was based on his experience working in 15 countries, and he divided the production into 12 separate sections based on factors such as farm size, mechanization, access to irrigation, and access to livestock. A list of 22 different regenerative practices was discussed, each evaluated from a feasibility standpoint. It was pointed out that the implications, risks, and unintended consequences of these practices, as well as the necessary changes, were significant points of consideration. He also introduced a four-scale feasibility of the adoption rating system.
Dr. Hake noted that his analysis was subjective and may be subject to further discussion and revisions. The main intent was to stimulate discussion on the feasibility, implications, and risks of agricultural practices for diverse production systems worldwide.
Discussion and Comments from Participants
The members were encouraged to share their thoughts on moving the document forward, including any missing elements or areas that needed further detail or explanation.
Mr. James Soth raised a comment about reaching a consensus on the report. He reminded the group about their prior procedures for handling situations where full consensus wasn’t reached. He suggested one option: presenting the paper as still under discussion and inviting ICAC members to contribute their questions and potential additions.
Ms. Elke Hortmeyer raised a question about the potential for the report’s findings to be used as legal advice for ICAC member countries, brands, and standards. Ms. Ruiz from the ICAC clarified that while they couldn’t make the report’s recommendations mandatory, the report could stimulate discussions in other ICAC committees.
Mr. Fabio Carneiro raised a question about the role of technology and precision agriculture in improving regenerative practices and collecting data. He suggested it could be a significant point to consider.
Dr. Ryan Kurtz suggested adding citations to the report to strengthen it if it is intended to be external. He also asked for clarification about a section of the Excel spreadsheet that included journal article citation percentages and practitioner citation percentages. Dr. Hake confirmed that these were two additional components that needed to be worked on and agreed to include references and citations to the report.
Dr. Marcelo Paytas shared his experiences of working on regenerative practices with grain farmers in Argentina. He suggested that such practices might also be feasible for small cotton farmers.
Mr. Leon Picon mentioned that despite not being an agronomist, he appreciated the comprehensive nature of the draft report. He suggested that the report could help standardize the understanding and application of regenerative agriculture within the cotton industry. He also proposed it’s the right time for the SEEP to raise this subject for policymakers, considering the potential need for regulation in different parts of the world. He suggested that the report could benefit from a set of suggestions or proposals for ICAC members on how to proceed with regenerative agriculture, given the lack of a standard definition and varied interpretations of the concept.
Mr. Jens Soth agreed with the idea of dividing the document into two components: the current discussion and a section for proactive suggestions from members. He emphasized that it would not be problematic to communicate that the document was a work in progress. He also mentioned a study he had commissioned to compare all regenerative standards with an accreditation system, which could provide additional credibility.
Seep members discussed the role of ICAC in recommending and providing definitions of regenerative agriculture. They agreed that ICAC is in a unique position to provide such information and should not solely rely on standards from other organizations. Members acknowledged the importance of delivering the information in a manner that is understandable to ICAC delegates from different countries, considering their varying levels of familiarity with such practices. They agreed that rushing to deliver a final document for the upcoming PM meeting is unnecessary. They expressed the intention to provide a draft for discussion, with the final product to come in the future. It also discussed the objective of the report and how it should inform whether to include regenerative agriculture in the ICAC multi-year agenda.
Next Steps:
Dr. Kater will provide a revised version of the report that includes the benefits of regenerative agriculture. Citations and references will be included after the PM in India.
There was unanimous agreement among SEEP members regarding the crucial need for an introductory section in the report. This introduction is intended to explain the report’s purpose and provide context to the ongoing discussions about regenerative agriculture. However, the objective of crafting this comprehensive introduction within the challenging timeframe of the next ten days was acknowledged.
Ms. Lorena Ruiz will be engaging in discussions with Alan Williams, the chair of SEEP, to review and address the comments and recommendations made by the panel members.
The distribution of the meeting minutes and the revised version of the report is scheduled for the week commencing on 27 November.
Other matters
Ms. Lorena Ruiz thanked all the members for their participation and invaluable input. The meeting was officially adjourned at 8:00 am Eastern Time (ET).
Dr Mansurbek Muminov is a senior scientist at the Scientific Research Institute of Fiber Crops in Uzbekistan. His efforts have focused on basic cotton ginning and spinning, and he has authored more than 10 comprehensive research papers in those areas.
Dr. Keshav R. Kranthi, Ph.D is the Chief Scientist at the International Cotton Advisory Committee (ICAC), Washington, DC. Before joining the ICAC, he served as the Director of the Central Institute for Cotton Research (CICR) in Nagpur, India, from 2008 to 2017. Dr. Kranthi has thirty-five years of experience as a cotton scientist. He received a gold medal in his Ph.D. in 1991 and has been honored with more than a dozen awards, including the Best CPP Program Award for Research Leadership by the Renewable Natural Resources Research International, UK; the ICAC Researcher of the Year Award in 2009; the Vasantrao Naik Smruti Pratisthan Award in 2004; the ICAR National Award for Leader of Best Team Research in 2006; Fellow of the National Academy of Agricultural Sciences in 2009; the ISCI Recognition Award in 2010; Krishi Gaurav Award in 2010; Bhumi Nirman Award in 2011; ISCI Fellow in 2017; the Plant Protection Recognition Award in 2016 by the National Academy of Agricultural Sciences; Suresh Kotak Global Cotton Award in 2023 and the CRDA life time achievement Award in 2024. Dr. Kranthi has four patents granted in South Africa, Mexico, China, and Uzbekistan, and six patent applications in India. He has published more than 100 peer-reviewed research papers, 20 books/handbooks/manuals, 17 book chapters, and more than 50 popular articles. Dr. Kranthi has presented invited talks and conducted training sessions in more than 40 countries. His research citations are in excess of 6,500. As the chief principal investigator, he coordinated and led more than 35 externally funded international collaboration research projects.
Dr. Charudatta Mayee, Ph.D is a distinguished Indian agricultural scientist and administrator with over five decades of contributions to Indian agriculture. Dr. Mayee currently serves as Adjunct Professor at IARI, New Delhi, and several ICAR institutions and universities. Dr Mayee served as Vice Chancellor of MAU Parbhani, Director of the Central Institute for Cotton Research (ICAR-CICR), Nagpur, and Agriculture Commissioner for the Government of India. Dr Mayee served as Vice President of the National Academy of Agricultural Sciences (NAAS) India. Dr. C.D. Mayee has received numerous accolades spanning five decades, recognizing his transformative contributions to agricultural science. He is an Alexander von Humboldt Fellow and has received lifetime achievement awards from multiple institutions. His early career was marked by the Prof. M.J. Narasimhan Academic Award (1974) and V.P. Gokhale Award (1998), followed by national honors like the Vasantrao Naik Krishi Award (2002), ICAR Outstanding Team Research Award (2003), and Dr. B. Vishwanath Award (2005). He received Lifetime Achievement Awards from the Indian Society for Cotton Improvement (2008), National Academy of Agricultural Sciences (2011), and Indian Phytopathological Society (2017), among others. Four universities conferred Honorary Doctorates (D.Sc.) for his pioneering work (2009–2023). Recent distinctions include the Best Cotton Scientist Award (2022, Cotton Association of India), Krishi Maharshi for Cotton R&D (2024) and the winner of the ICAC Researcher of the Year Award 2025.
Dr. Khalid Mahmood is the Co-Founder of SAWiE, where he has been instrumental in developing digital farm advisory and farm data platforms supporting over 10,000 farmers in Pakistan, improving traceability and transparency across agricultural supply chains. He is leading the development of first-mile traceability systems and the TRUE Cotton platform, connecting farmers with sustainable global textile supply chains.
Dr Olivier Zieschank studied Management at the university of Lausanne, where he graduated in 2005. Until 2010, he worked in a Swiss-based start-up that specialized in negotiating cell tower lease agreements, where he became associate director. In 2010, he returned to university and studied applied economics in Neuchatel, Switzerland. He wrote his PhD in Economics at the University of Freiberg, Germany, where he developed a theory of organization. Mr Zieschank was appointed Economist at the ITMF in August 2017 and became director in January 2021.
Ashwin Chandran holds a Bachelors Degree in Textile Technology from UMIST, UK and a Masters degree in Business Administration from the University of Illinois, USA.
Mr. Shreyans Gupta is an officer of the Indian Revenue Service (IRS), currently serving as First Secretary at the Embassy of India in Washington D.C. In his current role, he oversees critical portfolios within the Income-tax Overseas Unit (ITOU) and the Commerce Wing, facilitating bilateral and multilateral cooperation.
Eric Trachtenberg is the Executive Director of the International Cotton Advisory Committee (ICAC).
Pia Terasa joined the textile machinery manufacturer Saurer over 25 years ago. She is responsible for marketing and communications at the group level. Coming originally from a non-textile background, market intelligence and business development have played major roles throughout her career. Her current main “hobby” is closely monitoring development of the textile recycling industry and circular economy.
Dr. Md. Fakhre Alam Ibne Tabib is the former Executive Director of the Cotton Development Board of Bangladesh, with over 32 years of experience in cotton production, research, and development. He has demonstrated strong leadership and communication skills in engaging with national and international stakeholders in the cotton sector.
Dr. Elsie Sia Kanza is the current Ambassador Extraordinary and Plenipotentiary of the United Republic of Tanzania to the United States of America and Mexico. Prior to that role, Ambassador Kanza served as Special Advisor to the President of the World Economic Forum, and, before that, Head of Africa and Member of Executive Committee for 10 years championing growth and development in Africa leveraging public private collaboration. In 2015, She was awarded a Doctorate in Business Administration (honoris causa) by the University of Strathclyde for the transformative impact achieved in Africa.
Alison Ward has over 30 years of international experience in sustainability and corporate affairs. Alison is the CEO of CottonConnect, where she leads a team of over 100 employees, impacting the lives of over 800,000 cotton farmers in India, China, Pakistan, Turkey, Egypt and Bangladesh. Under Alison’s leadership the organization: drives supply chain transparency connecting sustainable fibres from farm to store; focuses on the rights and skills of women in supply chains through pioneering gender programmes; and continues to develop innovations at a farm level. She leads cotton strategies and programmes for global brands and retailers.


Name: Mary Concilia Anchang
Besim Özek
SIDDHARTHA RAJAGOPAL, Executive Director – TEXPROCIL